Yearly Archives: 2024

Assessment the latest Replace Theory: A step-By-Action Means

However, merely recently has actually researchers started to scrutinize the methods familiar with take to the latest theory. Into the a criticism of books, Rosenfeld (2005) renowned between “simple” and you can “complex” answers to comparison the newest change hypothesis. As he observed, early studies depending on cross-tabulations to evaluate whether interracial marriage ceremonies had a tendency to be designed by the whites that have lower training marrying highly experienced blacks basically refused the replace hypothesis (Bernard 1966; Heer 1974; Monahan 1976). By comparison, current education playing with “complex” log-linear designs have have a tendency to served the latest hypothesis (Schoen and you will Wooldredge 1989; Kalmijn 1993; Qian 1997; Fu 2001; Gullickson 2006; Gullickson and you can Torche 2014; Torche and you may Steeped 2016). Rosenfeld’s very own desires were to use easy methods just like the performance out of state-of-the-art activities confidence design assumptions, while “[s]imple tabular analyses at the least feel the advantage of visibility” (). However, the guy did not explain as to the reasons “simple” and you may “complex” tactics usually produce reverse results.

As race–degree replace hypothesis is intricate more than 70 years back because of the Merton (1941) and you may Davis (1941), many reports enjoys made an effort to ensure or reject they

In their answers so you can Rosenfeld (2005), Gullickson and you can Fu (2010) and you can Kalmijn (2010) dispute into “complex” log-linear acting approach but, including Rosenfeld, did not systematically talk about why this new “simple” therefore the “complex” methods give various other show.